Skip to main content

A reply to Salon's R. J. Eskrow, and his 11 stupid questions about Libertarians

Posts here have been in short supply as I have been living life and trying to get a campaign off the ground.

But "11 questions to see if Libertarians are hypocrites" by R. J. Eskrow, picked up at Salon, was just so freaking lame that I spent half an hour answering them.

In the end (but I'll leave it to your judgment), it is not that Libertarians or Libertarian theory looks hypocritical, but that the best that can be said for Mr. Eskrow is that he doesn't have the faintest clue what he's talking about.

That's ok, because even ill-informed attacks by people like this make an important point:  Libertarian ideas (as opposed to Conservative ideas, which are completely different) are making a comeback as the dynamic counterpoint to "politics as usual," and so every hack you can imagine must be dragged out to refute them.

Ergo:  Mr. Eskrow's 11 questions, with answers:

1.      Are unions, political parties, elections, and social movements like Occupy examples of “spontaneous order”—and if not, why not?

Of course they are, with the exception of elections.  [Elections are very obviously NOT an example of spontaneous order, but the result of conscious, centralized planning. They are also not congruent with the other items on Mr. Eskrow’s list, because an election is a process rather than a group of people.]  Unfortunately Mr. Eskrow starts off with an immediate lack of understanding of any serious Libertarian theory:  people have the right to organize for any peaceful purpose whether I or anybody else agrees with it or not.  It is only when such emergent movements engage in force or fraud that a Libertarian would object to their existence.  That doesn’t, however, mean that I or anybody else has any obligation whatsoever not to criticize them or work against them, likewise without the use of force or fraud.

2.      Is a libertarian willing to admit that production is the result of many forces, each of which should be recognized and rewarded?

Mr. Eskrow loves to create straw men.  Production involves all sorts of forces, from raw materials to workers to distribution networks to investors ad infinitum, ad nauseam.  It’s the second part of his question that becomes more panderingly simplistic than the rest of his article.  Who exactly should be doing the “recognizing” and “rewarding”?  Allowing that markets with their imperfections and externalities haven’t always measured up [especially in cases of crony capitalism, on which more below], it’s really important to notice that governments haven’t consistently done a great job, either.  The implicit assumption underlying Mr. Eskrow’s question is that government must intervene to guarantee that each (presumably human) “force” in production is “recognized and rewarded.”  Market anarchists (a subset of Libertarians that Mr. Eskrow never seems to have encountered) would make strong arguments that without the props provided to corporations by governments, a truly free market would result in a better distribution of profits and rewards.

3.      Is our libertarian willing to acknowledge that workers who bargain for their services, individually and collectively, are also employing market forces?

Gee, I guess so.  This Libertarian was a union president for six years.  Where I think Mr. Eskrow is way the hell out in right field (yes, “right”) is that he apparently doesn’t understand that Libertarians object to such legislation as the National Labor Relations Act and Taft-Hartley because under the guise of providing government supervision of labor relations, what the State really did was eviscerate the power of unions by making many of their most effective tactics against the corporations illegal.  Stop wasting your time reading Ayn Rand and start reading Kevin Carson.

4.      Is our libertarian willing to admit that a “free market” needs regulation?

The key concept of Libertarianism is the avoidance of force and fraud.  Most (excepting true market anarchists/mutualists) would accept the idea that regulation by government or courts to insure those tenets are not violated is completely legitimate, absolutely necessary.  Libertarians would point out, however, that it is often the case that private entities can provide regulation of free market activities just as efficiently (or even more efficiently) than the government [e.g. Underwriter’s Laboratories].

5.      Does our libertarian believe in democracy? If yes, explain what’s wrong with governments that regulate.

Democracy is a great process, but it is not—as the Framers knew—a great way to run a government, at least not via unfettered, direct democracy.  Just because I am able to manage 50% plus one vote does not mean, for example, that the government should be empowered to eliminate somebody’s inherent rights, nor does having a majority agree make any proposition inherently right, only more popular than others among those who do vote.  For example, the US and State governments imposed and enforced segregation laws for decades that were popular with the majority of voters.  Does Mr. Eskrow defend such laws based purely on the fact that the regulations were promulgated and enforced by democratically elected governments?

6.      Does our libertarian use wealth that wouldn’t exist without government in order to preach against the role of government?

Mr. Eskrow prides himself on having developed the “who would build the roads” argument, when he has merely discovered an economic dynamic that’s been understood for a long, long time.  Sophisticated societies at the agricultural, pre-industrial, industrial, or post-industrial levels require a significant infrastructure and protection from external destructive forces to operate.  Gee, even the Romans, the Persians, the Zimbabweans, and the Incas knew that.  The question becomes one of what is the most effective (and just) way to provide that infrastructure?  There, if you’re honest, the question becomes considerably murkier in a world of governments, trans-national corporations, non-governmental organizations, foundations, etc. etc. all pretty much run by an interchangeable class of elites, whose primary function seems to be a collective agreement to protect their wealth and privileges.

7.      Does our libertarian reject any and all government protection for his intellectual property?

This is really Mr. Eskrow’s only decent question, and it is already outmoded.  Writers like Kevin Carson and Thomas Knapp have changed my own thinking on this, to the point where I do reject government protection for my intellectual property.  Part of the reason for this shift is my understanding of how intellectual property protections are actually (a) exploited by large corporations using government force to lock other people out of the market; and (b) growing increasingly useless in an information age where the very definition of intellectual property is changing more rapidly than the most officious of governments can keep up.  Get into the digital age, Mr. Eskrow, and actually prove you’ve got an understanding of the issue before you start trying to score cheap points.

8.      Does our libertarian recognize that democracy is a form of marketplace?

Back to this one again.  Democracy is a “marketplace” of ideas, but the popularity of an idea does not give it moral force or justify the use of force or fraud against people who have not violated the same principles.  No vote by the American people should be able to remove my freedom of speech or freedom of religion, for example, because those areas have been declared off-limits to democracy as basic rights.  Again:  if a majority of people in the US voted to deny citizenship to children born in country due to the immigration status of their parents (“anchor babies”) would the popularity of that idea give it moral force?

9.      Does our libertarian recognize that large corporations are a threat to our freedoms?

More clearly, apparently, than Mr. Eskrow does.  Large corporations in their metastasized modern form are the creation of the government, specifically in a series of Supreme Court decisions in the 1870s-1880s, authored by Associate Justice Stephen J. Field, that extended 14th Amendment protections to “artificial persons” and declared them to be effectively immortal.  Corporations exist as tax farmers for the State, in return for which they received protectionist legislation at the expense of small businesses, individual entrepreneurs, workers, and consumers.  Moreover, the corporate elites move seamlessly into and out of government (hello, Goldmann Sachs, hello Treasury Department).  Mr. Eskrow, real Libertarians have been talking about this a lot longer than you have.

10.   Does he think that Rand was off the mark on this one, or does he agree that historical figures like King and Gandhi were “parasites”?

Ayn Rand, Mr. Eskrow, was an Objectivist who actually detested Libertarians.  The fact that many Libertarians and others inaccurately characterize her as the prime intellectual authority of Libertarian ideas has little or nothing to do with two centuries of Libertarian-oriented intellectual, social, and cultural thought that you are apparently wholly ignorant of.  Exactly what part of admiration for two social reformers who preached non-violence on the part of people whose guiding creed is “no force, no fraud” don’t you get?

11.   If you believe in the free market, why weren’t you willing to accept as final the judgment against libertarianism rendered decades ago in the free and unfettered marketplace of ideas?

And when would that have been, Mr. Eskrow?  Since you don’t actually have any understanding of Libertarian thought beyond saying, “Nyah, nyah, Ayn Rand was a selfish bitch,” then how would we expect you to understand that Libertarian ideals of a non-violent, non-coercive society don’t go out of style simply because your preferred crony capitalist state likes to distort them?  Marriage equality?  Advocated by Libertarians for many years.  Likewise marijuana legalization.  Non-interventionist foreign policy.  Limits on police powers of surveillance and arrest.  Libertarians have had an enormous impact on the social and political discussions of the past three decades, but you haven’t noticed, apparently because you were too busy decided which plutocrat (Democrat or Republican) to vote for.


Steve Boone said…
Bravo!!! Well reasoned and argued!
Anonymous said…
Whats more shocking....Biden gets his son Hunter a big job at Ukraine Gas company, think Big Opportunist, think who is destroying Ukraine, who is backing up the neo facists in Urkaine? see the News Journal for the particulars.
Anonymous said…
I just want point out on a different subject why Steve newton should be elected to office. If you read this article you will see how he is a layer and a racial bigot.
Steve Finnell said…

What is faith? Faith is believing in something you cannot prove.

Hebrews 11:1 Now faith is being sure of what we hope for and certain of what we do not see. (New International Version-1984)
Hebrews 11:1 Now faith is the assurance of thing hoped for, the conviction of things not seen. (New American Standard Bible)
Hebrews 11:1 Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. (King James Version)

I have faith that Jesus is the Son of God. I have faith that He performed miracles. I have faith that Jesus was resurrected from the grave by God the Father. I believe this because I have faith that the historical record of the Bible is accurate, yet I cannot prove it. There are no living eyewitness to confirm that Jesus was who He said He was or that He was resurrected from the dead, I accept it by faith, I believe it, however, I cannot prove it.

Atheists do not believe the fact that Jesus was the Son of God or that there even is a God, they cannot prove their unbelief, they accept it by faith.

Romans 8:24 For in hope we have been saved, but hope that is seen is not hope, for who hopes for what he already sees?(NASB)

We have hope we have been saved, but we hope because of faith. We cannot prove we have been saved. We believe that we have been saved because we believe, by faith, that the Bible is accurate and trustworthy.

John 20:27-31 Then He said to Thomas, "Reach here with you finger, see My hands and put them into my side; and do not be unbelieving, but believing." 28 Thomas answered and said to Him, "My Lord and my God!'29 Jesus said to him, "Because you have seen Me, have you believed? Blessed are they who did not see, and yet believed." ...... (NASB)

Thomas had proof that Jesus was resurrected from the grave. Men today cannot prove the resurrection of Jesus from the grave, they accept it by faith.

There were more than five hundred brethren, including the apostles, who saw Jesus alive after He faced death on the cross. They were eyewitnesses, they had proof of the resurrection of Jesus. (1 Corinthians 15:3-7)

Those of us alive today have to have FAITH that the Biblical accounts of Jesus and His resurrection are true. We cannot prove they are true. NO ONE IS ALIVE TODAY WHO WAS AN EYEWITNESS TO THE RESURRECTION OF JESUS.


NOTE: Atheists believe, by faith, that God does not exists, but they cannot prove it.

Dana Garrett said…
"...that without the props provided to corporations by governments, a truly free market would result in a better distribution of profits and rewards."

Like those "high" wages that international corporations pay workers in third world nations? The truth of the matter is that wages would be that abysmal everywhere if it weren't it weren't for the intervention of some governments.
Dana Garrett said…
"The key concept of Libertarianism is the avoidance of force and fraud." Do Libertarians include the necessity of regulating companies for worker safety? Would Osha go out the window in a Libertarian government?
Anonymous said…
Mr Newton,
I believe I live in your district. I can't *begin* to tell you how glad I am that your campaign for elective office failed.

I can't even *begin* to tell you how little your opinion means to me.
Pinky Sharma said…
Rather Easy Moving Top 20 Packers and movers
Pinky Sharma said…
Top 20 Packers and movers services of an expert Packers and Movers india.

Unknown said…
I absolutely admired every bit of it and i additionally accept you book apparent to analysis out fresh things in your site.
Bangalore Web Designing Company, Web Development Company Bangalore
Prasanth said…
Thanks for such avant-garde and amazing information..Good actuality is absolutely affable information.
UI Design Companies in Bangalore, Web Application Development Companies in Bangalore
Unknown said…
thank you for your article.I really liked your article because articles that you provide khayak provide many benefits to the public.DAFTAR IDN POKER.I will your next article and your next post.. thanks
Anonymous said…
Hey snowflake, did your feeling's get hurt lmao. Suck it up buttercup.A snowball stood a better chance at surviving in Hell more than you had at winning your campaign.

Thank you so much for the detailed article
Awesome post. Appreciate your efforts and really enjoyed the style of your writing.
I am agree with above point. You are such a nice author. I have already bookmark your domain for share it everywhere.
Suruchi Pandey said…
This is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. Therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. Professional Web design services are provided by W3BMINDS- Website designer in Lucknow.
Web development Company | Web design company

Techiesys said…
Your content is very neat and helpful Web Design Company Bangalore
Its very Wonder full blog.I found some knowledge full information in the blog. thanks for sharing valuable.very nice… i really like your blog…CheapWays Digital Marketing Company in Nagpur
Mr Rahman said…
Really Nice Post & keep up the good work.
Oflox Is The Best Website Design Company In Dehradun
mesin slot said…
King88Bet adalah master agen mesin slot dan terbaik di indonesia
Situs Judi Slot said…
King88Bet adalah master Situs Judi Slot online dan terbaik di indonesia
Togel Hari Ini said…
agenangka adalah master Togel Hari ini dan terbaik di indonesia
Fuel Digi said…
We are the Best Digital Marketing Agency in Chennai.Our team consists of very best of programmers,web developers,SEO experts and many others. we offer all digital marketing service at affordable cost.
Thanks for the article…
Best Pay Per Click Service in Chennai
Best Quality Content Marketing Team in Chennai
ECommerce website development company in Chennai
Best Logo Designing Company of Chennai
Simone Watson said…
Amazing write-up!! We are also serving business with solutions offered by amazon web services. Get in touch with us for the best consultation from us as a certified AWS Managed Service Partner.
Rahim Ladhani said…
I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. see the best mobile app development companies list.
Are you looking for cost accounting assignment help? Get Professional Assistance from Expert Writers at Affordable Prices.
It is a great blog, contains good information and is quite interactive. We are also dealing with the same kind of services such as coursework Help. Suppose you are looking for java homework help. We are here to help you out, and you can connect with us through chat or email or visit our website. We are providing coursework help in all subjects for the school, college and university students. We are the best in quality, and our content is unique. We always provide content before that deadline to get the chance to review the assignment before submission.
Continue reading: Assignment help
At Assignment Studio, we have professional assignment help on cert iv finance and mortgage broking expert to assist and provide you with affordable writing services.
It is a great blog, contains good information and is quite interactive. We are also dealing with the same kind of services such as Assignment Help online. Suppose you are looking for java homework help. We are here to help you out, and you can connect with us through chat or email or visit our website. We are providing coursework help in all subjects for the school, college and university students. We are the best in quality, and our content is unique. We always provide content before that deadline to get the chance to review the assignment before submission.
Continue reading: Pecha Kucha presentation
Hire our experts for online international economics assignment help at Assignment Studio at low prices.
Sarah Winget said…
Enjoy a reprieve from homework and restless evenings, rather get a specialist to compose every one of them for you. You can do your other significant work as opposed to wasting it in doing such mind boggling assignments. The best homework help is simply before you. Several nights and get uniquely custom-made homework from the top academic writers containing zero plagiarism, slip-up or errors. my assignment help
Emma Jackson said…
Goassignmenthelp is a team of leading professional writers for Assignment Help to students all around the world. Contact us today for the Best homework help online at a very affordable price. Hire native seasoned experts math homework help online at very affordable prices. We are the most reliable assignment helpers. We have gained our specialization after spending accounting homework help online most of our time making ourselves perfect.
We are a top rated economics assignment help Online service here with experts specializing in a wide range of disciplines ensuring you get the assignments that score maximum grades.
Ajay Sharma said…
Hello Writer, such a nice article written.
Good job thanks for posting such good content, We have skilled professional developers with 12+ years of experience. Also, our team gives 100% support after delivering a project. If you have any requirements regarding learning management system then you can contact us at +91- 9717270746.
ReadyTechno said…

Clayie is one of the Online Jhumka Delivery and Home Decor Items stores in India, also one of the leading Plants.
Buy Golden Jhumka
Buy Oxidized Earrings
Buy Oxidized Earring
Buy Oxidized Earrings
Buy Oxidized Earrings
Buy Oxidized Earrings
Anonymous said…
ij.start canon is the manufacturer's site to download Canon printer drivers. You can easily download the driver according to your model as ij start canon is designed with a user-friendly interface. Canon IJ Setup process takes a few minutes in device installation and software installation .
mack zayn said…
https //ij.start.cannon
https //ij.start.cannon
So how do you get the correct drivers and software for your Canon printer and install it to start printing quickly? Here’s everything (Guide) you should follow to set up your Canon IJ printer
123shopieketh said…
Install latest software and drivers of canon printer and plug in the USB cable to computer and printer. It’ll automatically be connected; however, you’ve to follow on-screen guidelines.
http //,
https //ij.start.cannon,

ethan potter said…
Canon IJ Network Tool is a toolkit software with the options to keep a check on most of your Canon printer network settings and adjust them according to your requirements. The Canon IJ Network tool will get you through the network settings uninterruptedly.Canon IJ Printer Utility is a complete software package meant to adjust and modify the configurations of your printer device as per the requirement.
Unknown said…

Visit and open the door to the world of HP smart printing solutions. HP wireless printer is a versatile printing device that helps you print, scan, copy and fax your documents as per the requirement.

Visit | ij.start canon and find out the best way to download Canon printer drivers.
Once you are done with the driver setup via , you will have to insert a pile of pages into the printer tray for printing the documents.

st.johns said…
St John’s School is one of the top ICSE Schools situated at Hebbal, North Bangalore, Karnataka. We believe in providing all-round development with academic excellence to our students. In order to achieve this we have a team of dedicated teachers who channelize their energy and resources towards child-centered qualitative learning. We help students gain a strong foundation and develop into holistic beings. During these years, the smooth transition from childhood to adolescence is facilitated by value-added education
Leo Oliver said…

Business Economics is a fast economics course that focuses on budget management and consistently provides excellent assignment answers. Students should contact assignment writers as soon as feasible for quick assignment assistance since authors will complete the work as soon as possible after getting the feedback. Business Economics Assignment Help
Kevin Smith said…
Contact us to get the Logistic Management Assignment Help and achieve a high score in the assignment. We assure to deliver high-quality content within no time. We remain dedicated to the students and follow their guidelines to provide them with the best content.

If you're in search of the Best assignment helper in Malaysia then hire the superb quality assignment help services from and get your assignments completed by experts.
uday said…
There will be best course in Hyderabad, duck creek policy program,duck creek can earn a salary 130000 per is useful to students career in the field you have interest visit my website link.thanks you
Nelson Lima said…
If you don't have an interest in a task then it’s hard for you to do an in-depth analysis on a particular subject assigned to you. Don't worry we are here to assist you. qqi assignments have proficient writers for analysis from top universities to deliver your dissertation writing service at a very cheap price with 100% security assurance.
Kaylee Brown said…
This comment has been removed by the author.

Popular posts from this blog

Comment Rescue (?) and child-related gun violence in Delaware

In my post about the idiotic over-reaction to a New Jersey 10-year-old posing with his new squirrel rifle , Dana Garrett left me this response: One waits, apparently in vain, for you to post the annual rates of children who either shoot themselves or someone else with a gun. But then you Libertarians are notoriously ambivalent to and silent about data and facts and would rather talk abstract principles and fear monger (like the government will confiscate your guns). It doesn't require any degree of subtlety to see why you are data and fact adverse. The facts indicate we have a crisis with gun violence and accidents in the USA, and Libertarians offer nothing credible to address it. Lives, even the lives of children, get sacrificed to the fetishism of liberty. That's intellectual cowardice. OK, Dana, let's talk facts. According to the Children's Defense Fund , which is itself only querying the CDCP data base, fewer than 10 children/teens were killed per year in Delaw

With apologies to Hube: dopey WNJ comments of the week

(Well, Hube, at least I'm pulling out Facebook comments and not poaching on your preserve in the Letters.) You will all remember the case this week of the photo of the young man posing with the .22LR squirrel rifle that his Dad got him for his birthday with resulted in Family Services and the local police attempting to search his house.  The story itself is a travesty since neither the father nor the boy had done anything remotely illegal (and check out the picture for how careful the son is being not to have his finger inside the trigger guard when the photo was taken). But the incident is chiefly important for revealing in the Comments Section--within Delaware--the fact that many backers of "common sense gun laws" really do have the elimination of 2nd Amendment rights and eventual outright confiscation of all privately held firearms as their objective: Let's run that by again: Elliot Jacobson says, This instance is not a case of a father bonding with h

A Libertarian Martin Luther King Jr. Day post

In which we travel into interesting waters . . . (for a fairly long trip, so be prepared) Dr. King's 1968 book, Where do we go from here:  chaos or community? , is profound in that it criticizes anti-poverty programs for their piecemeal approach, as John Schlosberg of the Center for a Stateless Society  [C4SS] observes: King noted that the antipoverty programs of the time “proceeded from a premise that poverty is a consequence of multiple evils,” with separate programs each dedicated to individual issues such as education and housing. Though in his view “none of these remedies in itself is unsound,” they “all have a fatal disadvantage” of being “piecemeal,” with their implementation having “fluctuated at the whims of legislative bodies” or been “entangled in bureaucratic stalling.”   The result is that “fragmentary and spasmodic reforms have failed to reach down to the profoundest needs of the poor.” Such single-issue approaches also have “another common failing — they are i