Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Star Trek

The Federation as an oppressive Nanny State: Star Trek vs Libertarian Capitalism

In a comment regarding my Just for Hube: Star Trek vs Battlestar Galactica post, Tom writes, "I would be interested to see a thorough social/political/economic analysis to Star Trek from a libertarian perspective." I was thinking about writing one, when I recalled my grandmother's constant admonition, "Try not to spend too much time doing what's already been done." (The other admonition that still sticks in my mind, the one about what would make me go blind if I didn't stop doing it, is the one I'm going to try to purge from the family line this generation.) So I went out and collected a few interesting links, only to discover that everybody pretty much mined that vein already. Still, it's worth gathering the references to a number of the better ones. In September 2007, National Review Online actually did a Star Trek Weekend , of which George Mason law professor Ilya Somin's Mamas, Don’t Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be Federation Tax Collect...

Just for Hube: Star Trek vs Battlestar Galactica

I'm talking about the two original series here: William Shatner vs Lorne Greene. Aside from the fact that BG suffered from bad writing and worse acting, I always thought that there was one particular reason why Galactica did not succeed in cultural terms like the original Star Trek franchise. Remember the two openings? Star Trek: "...to boldly go where no man has gone before...." Galactica: "...fleeing from the Zylon tyranny, the last Battlestar...." Here's the difference: In Star Trek, MAN happened to the universe. Kirk, Spock, Bones, and the rest went out into the starry deep determined to kick ass and take names. Yeah, they were often outgunned and had to cheat their way out, but the whole concept was a sort of "human manifest destiny"--those stars were eventually going to be ours. In Battlestar Galactica, the UNIVERSE happened to man. Humanity had already lost to the Zylons, and was fleeing, not exploring. Any ass-kicking done was always...