Skip to main content

New York's abortion battle heats up....

To begin with: I support abortion rights.

I refuse to equivocate any more and call myself Pro-Choice.

I also refuse to give up my gut-wrenching objection to abortion as a practice.

But I believe that a woman's right to control her own body trumps the State's so-called right to intrude therein.

So given that I'm a bundle of contradictions, this one's tough. New York Governor Elliot Spitzer is lobbying hard to have the Empire State legislature pass a law declaring abortion a "fundamental right." Opponents--which in NY State always includes a high percentage of my fellow Catholics--believe that this bill is aimed at creating a slippery slope, at whose bottom they will find religious hospitals required to perform abortions.

Not so, respond the bill's supporters.

So here's the controversy:

Church officials say the act goes much further. Among their concerns is a provision that expands the field of people who may legally perform abortions. The legislation would extend authority beyond physicians to "qualified, licensed health care practitioners." They also say the bill would eliminate the possibility of placing new restrictions on abortion, such as parental notification, informed consent laws, and waiting periods.

They say they are most troubled by a section that states that the "the state shall not discriminate against the exercise of the rights … in the regulation or provision of benefits, facilities, services, or information."

"If they grant us a license, which is a state action, they will be discriminating," a legal coordinator for the archdiocese, Edward Mechmann, said. "The right to abortion would have more protection under New York's law than the right to free exercise of religion."

Spitzer administration officials dispute the church's interpretation, arguing that a "conscience clause" provision in state law allowing physicians to refuse to perform abortions for religious reasons and federal laws prohibiting the federal government from requiring doctors, hospitals, or clinics to perform abortions would protect Catholic hospitals and social-service agencies from legal penalties.

"Nobody will be required to perform an abortion," an assistant counsel to the governor, Lisa Ullman, said in an interview.


I have to be honest in that I think the Catholic Church is gazing over a slippery slope that in this instance exists only in the minds of the Bishops. Despite various blog and talk radio reports, I can't find anything that seriously moves in the direction of telling hospitals, "OK, buddy, get that gurney rolling. I'm here with the D&C police to make sure you take care of this young woman's mistake."

However, I am extremely troubled by the idea that New York is moving to let "qualified, licensed health care practitioners," who need not necessarily be doctors, handle abortions. This seems to open the doors for physician's assistant, nurse practitioners, or even midwives to offer abortion services. That scares me. Abortion is generally considered surgery, and surgery is generally considered the province of doctors.

But if you have only heard of this issue in sound bites over the past couple of days, you really need to read the article.

[Almost completely tangential aside to Jason, should he ever drift by:

Which Yoda?


1) The animatronic robot with no brain in The Empire Strikes Backs, whose lines are written by a millionaire movie producer?

OR

2) The fictive dwarf Jedi Knight who, instead of sticking around to organize the resistance, ran away to a swamp world and brewed himself tea while the Death Star sterilized entire planets?

It seems to me that the only person Yoda would have the moral authority to tweak would be, oh I don't know, a second-rate actor playing a late-blooming teenager who fell in love with his own sister....]

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Obligatory Libertarian Tax Day Post

The most disturbing factoid that I learned on Tax Day was that the average American must now spend a full twenty-four hours filling out tax forms. That's three work days. Or, think of it this way: if you had to put in two hours per night after dinner to finish your taxes, that's two weeks (with Sundays off). I saw a talking head economics professor on some Philly TV channel pontificating about how Americans procrastinate. He was laughing. The IRS guy they interviewed actually said, "Tick, tick, tick." You have to wonder if Governor Ruth Ann Minner and her cohorts put in twenty-four hours pondering whether or not to give Kraft Foods $708,000 of our State taxes while demanding that school districts return $8-10 million each?

New Warfare: I started my posts with a discussion.....

.....on Unrestricted warfare . The US Air force Institute for National Security Studies have developed a reasonable systems approach to deter non-state violent actors who they label as NSVA's. It is an exceptionally important report if we want to deter violent extremism and other potential violent actors that could threaten this nation and its security. It is THE report our political officials should be listening to to shape policy so that we do not become excessive in using force against those who do not agree with policy and dispute it with reason and normal non-violent civil disobedience. This report, should be carefully read by everyone really concerned with protecting civil liberties while deterring violent terrorism and I recommend if you are a professional you send your recommendations via e-mail at the link above so that either 1.) additional safeguards to civil liberties are included, or 2.) additional viable strategies can be used. Finally, one can only hope that politici

More of This, Please

Or perhaps I should say, "Less of this one, please." Or how about just, "None of them. Ever again. Please....For the Love of God." Sunshine State Poll: Grayson In Trouble The latest Sunshine State/VSS poll shows controversial Democratic incumbent Alan Grayson trailing former state Senator Dan Webster by seven points, 43 percent to 36 percent. A majority of respondents -- 51 percent -- disapprove of the job that Grayson is doing. Independents have an unfavorable view of him as well, by a 36/47 margin. Grayson has ignored the conventional wisdom that a freshman should be a quiet member who carefully tends to the home fires. The latest controversy involves his " Taliban Dan " advertisement, where he explicitly compares his opponent to the Taliban, and shows a clip of Webster paraphrasing Ephesians 5:22 -- "wives, submit to your husbands." An unedited version of the clip shows that Webster was actually suggesting that husba